Cash for Cards

Turn your Cards into Cash!

We strive to offer competitive pricing, typically paying 70-90% of comps for graded cards and 50-70% for raw cards. We'll always aim for a fair deal. Many factors can determine the percentage we would offer for the card including: player star power, health, on/off field issues, current market conditions, and the overall condition of the card or graded slab. We reserve the right to decline to purchase any item. Our team carefully considers multiple elements when determining the offer percentage, guaranteeing a comprehensive and objective assessment of the card's value.

We offer 70% store credit and 50% cash for Pokémon alternate arts, secret art rares, special art rares, WotC (Wizrd of the Coast) holos, and illustration rares everyday!

What We're Currently Buying:

  • Vintage cards of stars (pre-1980). In particular, we are looking for cards 1969 or earlier.
  • Complete sets from 1980 or earlier
  • Rookie cards of elite hall of famers from 1986 and before.
  • Rare inserts from the 1990’s of hall of famers players only.
  • Modern (2000-present) stars, including rookie cards, autograph/patch cards, and numbered parallels/short prints.
  • Pokémon alternate arts, secret art rares, special art rares, WotC (Wizrd of the Coast) holos, and illustration rares.
  • Graded cards of all sports and TCG/Pokémon
  • Select factory-sealed Pokémon boxes/cases
  • Select Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, and YuGiOh! singles valued over $20 per card.

What We're NOT Currently Buying:

  • Cards from the 1980’s and 1990’s that are either: not graded, not a rookie of a GOAT, not a rarer insert or refractor. Unfortunately manufacturers overprinted cards during this “junk wax” era, so there is little value and demand for 99% of the cards from this era.
  • Common cards from 1960 to present.
  • Modern base cards.
  • Common inserts or non-numbered parallels of any athlete that's not an elite rookie or likely hall of famer.
  • Autographed memorabilia
  • Pokemon Bulk Cards
  • Any Magic: The Gathering, One Piece, Disney Lorcana, or YuGiOh! singles valued under $20 per card.

Ready to Sell?

  • If you have 25 or less cards to sell, feel free to stop in any time for a free appraisal and offer for your cards! This process should usually take 15 minutes or less!

For larger collections (over 25 cards):

  • Personalized Service: We recommend scheduling an appointment to ensure a smooth and efficient experience. This way, we can dedicate focused time to appraising your collection.
  • Easy Scheduling: Simply email a few photos of your cards and a brief description of what you're selling to help@collectorsrow.cards. We'll confirm our interest and schedule a convenient time to review your collection in detail.

How Do I Know What My Cards Are Worth?
While there are many resources available, a great starting point to find recent card sale prices is www.130point.com. It's important to remember that listed prices on platforms like eBay don't always reflect actual value. Just because a card is listed for a certain amount doesn't mean it will sell for that price. To determine fair market value, we rely on data that shows what cards have actually sold for recently.